Is CounterMail Safe? Diskless Servers, Closed Source

CounterMail runs diskless web servers and OpenPGP encryption with 4096-bit keys, but its closed-source code has never been independently audited.

Ahsan Luqman
Ahsan Luqman
·10 min read·

CounterMail is a Swedish encrypted email service that encrypts mail with OpenPGP on RSA 4096-bit keys and runs its web servers without hard drives, yet its code is closed source and no independent audit of that code or of its no-logs claim has ever been published. The service is also closed for new registrations, so most readers cannot open an account at all. The safety question therefore splits in two: the architecture is unusually hardened, and the verification is unusually thin.

Registration and pricing#

Closed to new users

CounterMail's services page states twice that the service is closed for new registrations, with a 10-day trial only for people who already know a CounterMail user.

The services page carries the closed-registration statement twice, in prominent wording, and a reader without an existing CounterMail contact cannot open an account at all. The Mailfence comparison, updated in October 2025, records the same position: registration needs an invite code from an existing user.

Secondary reviews report a 7-day trial, while the provider's own page states 10 days. The primary source takes precedence, so this article uses 10 days.

There is no free tier. One plan covers three durations, with identical features and 4 GB of storage at each length.

DurationPriceStorage
6 months$294 GB
12 months$494 GB
24 months$794 GB
Data comparison table

Payment runs by card through Stripe or by wire transfer, and Bitcoin appears at the same prices on the site, yet the changelog states that Bitcoin payment was disabled for new accounts in June 2024. Extra storage costs a one-time fee from $19 for 250 MB to $89 for 1.75 GB, no monthly subscription exists, and buying five or more accounts brings a discount starting at 15 percent. Cloudwards records a 14-day money-back guarantee on top of the trial. It lists the absence of a free plan and of native apps among the main drawbacks. NoKYC Score records that no operating company is named on the provider's own pages and that no incidents are on record.

History and features#

Founder Simon Persson registered the domain in 2008 and opened the service in May 2010, after using Hushmail for years and deciding in 2007 that it could disable encryption for individual users. The founder interview records these dates and the Hushmail decision in his own words.

Mail runs through a webmail application, with IMAP access for third-party clients and no native mobile or desktop app of its own. SafeBox, a password manager, sits alongside the mail. Secure web forms, a calendar, an XMPP chat server, and custom domain support for a one-time $15 setup fee complete the package.

Premium accounts get up to 10 aliases, with @cmail.nu copies added automatically, and every new account also receives a random member alias, as CounterMail's own support pages confirm.

Encryption and key storage#

CounterMail encrypts mail with OpenPGP, the standard defined in RFC 4880 of November 2007, with the key pair generated in the browser at signup. Incoming mail is encrypted to the user's public key on arrival. Mail to another OpenPGP user is end-to-end encrypted, while mail to anyone else travels under TLS only.

The keys are RSA 4096-bit keys, and the support pages accept self-generated RSA keys of 2048 or 4096 bits.

By default the private key lives on a CounterMail Key Server, inside a package encrypted with AES-256-CBC and indexed anonymously, while all crypto operations happen on the user's own computer and the password that decrypts the key is never stored. The private-key protection paper from August 2017 sets out this design in full.

Storage on the provider's servers remains a trust decision the user cannot avoid at signup, and the user can delete the private key from CounterMail servers, which the founder recommends only for advanced users. Deleting it means the webmail interface can no longer display messages directly. Messages must be downloaded and decrypted locally instead.

Changing to a key the user already owns is also awkward: the support FAQ states that the user must send the keys to accounts@countermail.com from their CounterMail address, encrypted and signed with the old key. There is no password recovery. The private key is encrypted with the password, and both are needed to open the account.

OpenPGP encrypts the message body but not the subject line, so CounterMail adds an extra RSA and AES-CBC layer to encrypt subjects, as TechRadar notes. Metadata still passes through the provider, as it must for any mail service to deliver mail. The question of whether an email provider can read your emails applies here as everywhere.

Diskless servers and IP handling#

CounterMail's web servers have no hard drives, boot from CD-ROM, and sit between the user and the mail servers as a filter. The how-it-works page states that the web server does not log any IP addresses and that if someone steals it they will find nothing on it. The user's computer never has any direct contact with the mail servers.

The mail servers do use hard drives, but every message stored there was already encrypted on the user's computer before it arrived, so the diskless design protects the connection layer rather than the storage layer: it stops IP addresses and session data from being written to a disk on the internet-facing server.

CounterMail also strips IP addresses from the headers of outgoing mail and states that it never logs customer IP addresses. ProPrivacy describes the diskless servers as a filter that scrubs IP addresses before encrypted messages pass to the mail servers, which is a claim about the provider's own conduct rather than a fact an outsider can verify.

USB key login#

CounterMail offers login with a USB key as well as a password: a 512-bit key file sits on a USB 2.0 or 3.0 drive formatted to FAT32, and both the password and the key file are needed to open the account, with the option included free in all premium subscriptions. It protects the account even if the password is phished or guessed, because credential stuffing tries passwords leaked from other services, and a hardware key file blocks that whole class of attack.

AliasFleet and CounterMail#

AliasFleet provides managed, persistent forwarding addresses, and a CounterMail account can sit behind them as the destination inbox. Mail sent to an alias forwards to the CounterMail address, replies travel back through the alias, and websites never receive the CounterMail address itself. The free plan from AliasFleet includes 10 active aliases and 50 MB of monthly forwarding bandwidth.

This arrangement fits CounterMail well. The CounterMail address is hard to replace, because the account is closed to new registrations and losing access to the account means losing the address, so keeping that address out of circulation protects it.

CounterMail's own aliases also have a flaw that AliasFleet aliases do not. ProPrivacy reports that a deleted CounterMail alias can be registered again by someone else. An AliasFleet alias is disabled rather than recycled, so mail to a disabled alias stops instead of going to a stranger.

The alias layer changes what is exposed, not what CounterMail can read: mail forwarded to CounterMail is still mail held by CounterMail. An alias keeps the CounterMail address out of circulation. It lets the holder cut off a single alias when a service leaks it, as described in how email aliases actually work, whether email aliases are safe, and different email for every website. Banking follows the same separation. A permanent real address is kept only for financial accounts, as described in should you use a separate email for banking. Account recovery should never depend on an alias that can be disabled.

Swedish jurisdiction#

CounterMail is based and hosted in Sweden, a member of the 14 Eyes surveillance agreement, where a law passed in 2009, the FRA law, allows the National Defence Radio Authority to wiretap telephone and internet traffic crossing Sweden's borders for national security reasons, according to ProPrivacy. Swedish ISPs have refused to cooperate with data retention directives, and Swedish authorities can also compel a provider of encrypted services to hand over information needed to execute a warrant.

CounterMail's answer to that jurisdiction problem is end-to-end encryption. Mail encrypted to the recipient's key is not readable from a warrant as long as the key handling holds. CounterMail's own pages do not discuss Swedish law.

The same review notes that CounterMail promises to delete all transaction data within two weeks. The site uses no cookies and no trackers, while the privacy policy itself is a short bullet list rather than a full policy.

Verification limits#

CounterMail's core problem is not a flaw in its design but the fact that the design cannot be checked. The software is closed source, no independent audit of the code or of the no-logs claim has been published, and ProPrivacy states this directly.

Smaller gaps sit next to the closed code: a thin privacy policy, no named operating company, a key-change process that asks the user to email keys to the provider, and recycled aliases. None of these proves wrongdoing, yet together they mean the service asks for more trust than its competitors while offering less evidence.

The safety claim is unverifiable, which is a narrower conclusion than unsafe. The encryption standard is open, and the private key handling is documented by the provider in its own paper, but what cannot be verified is whether the running code does what the documents say. A reader who accepts that gap gets a hardened mailbox with strong defaults, while a reader who does not should pick a provider whose code is public and whose no-logs claim has been audited.

CounterMail is the only provider in this site's safety series with this shape. Is Mailfence Safe?, Is Posteo Safe?, Is Runbox Safe?, and Is Atomic Mail Safe? cover providers with different trade-offs.

The findings in brief#

CounterMail is a Swedish encrypted email service with OpenPGP encryption on RSA 4096-bit keys, diskless web servers that boot from CD-ROM and log no IP addresses, and USB-key login. Premium costs $29 for six months, $49 for twelve months, or $79 for twenty-four months. Storage is 4 GB, and there is no free tier. The private key is stored on CounterMail servers in encrypted form by default and can be deleted by the user. The software is closed source. It has never been independently audited, so the strongest claims about logging and key handling cannot be checked by anyone outside the provider. Anyone using any provider should check whether their address has already appeared in a breach. Have I Been Pwned lists breaches, and how to check if your email was leaked sets out the steps.

Frequently asked questions

CounterMail has strong encryption and diskless web servers, but its code is closed source and has never been independently audited, so the safety claims rest on trust in the provider. The service is also closed for new registrations, so most readers cannot open an account at all.

No. There is a 10-day trial for people who already know a CounterMail user, and after that the only option is a paid subscription at $29 for six months, $49 for twelve months, or $79 for twenty-four months, with 4 GB of storage.

Yes, by default. The private key is stored on CounterMail servers in encrypted form, and the user can delete it. Deleting the key means the webmail interface can no longer display messages directly, and messages must be downloaded and decrypted locally instead.

No. CounterMail runs closed-source software that has never been independently audited, according to ProPrivacy. The encryption standard it uses, OpenPGP, is open, but the provider's own code cannot be inspected by the public.

Never expose your real email address again

Generate private forwarding addresses for newsletters, shops, and apps. Reply through aliases and disable any address with one click if it ever leaks.

Two-way alias repliesCustom domain routingEmail tracker blocking
Get Started FreeView plansFree tier available · No credit card required
Ahsan Luqman

Founder of AliasFleet. Building tools to protect personal inboxes from spam and data breaches.

More articles

All articles